Looking at my two current sweater projects provides perfect examples of how my knitting remains yarn-driven. The first sweater project stretched out over two years with relatively little effort. It started with the yarn I found in a bin in the sock yarn section of a shop in Kansas City--Koigu Kersti in a deep, mottled purple. I bought only four hanks of the semi-solid purple and one of a cream with purple flecks that looked good with it, a total of 570 yards of dk-weight yarn. At the time, having never knit a full-size sweater, I thought that was plenty. Since then, I've often seen a pattern that I thought might do, but never was I convinced enough to even swatch. I actually found a pattern in my
Knitting New Scarves book that is intended for Kersti. I tried it and couldn't get gauge. It looked awful. Thank goodness I ripped it out, for now I have this:
Last month I bought the Spring issue of Vogue Knitting and found the Ripple cardigan, a pattern for a sweater in different colorways of Koigu. It requires Mori, which is a lighter weight than Kersti, but, since it is a top-down raglan, I figured I could just stop knitting when it fit right. It turned out to be just the right thing for this yarn, and allowed me to use bits of other dk and sock-weight yarn I had. I only bought one additional color, the solid brown. Sometimes things just work out with little effort involved.
Then there's the Jaeger Aqua yarn, the yarn for which so many patterns have been considered and discarded. This project actually didn't start with the yarn but with the pattern, the
Swooping Eyelet pullover. I actually bought the yarn to knit this pattern. I bought one ball of a color that appeared to be (on my monitor) a light gray. In reality, it is lavender. I swatched, liked the look but not the color and ordered 13 balls in a dark brown. With the brown, things changed--mostly the texture and softness of the yarn. Once I swatched, I decided that it was the wrong gauge, was too hard and didn't look good in plain stockinette. It is so true that the same yarn in a different color can feel and behave differently (must be the dye).
As I hesitated to knit the Eyelet pullover, I reviewed the pattern. The very first thing that put me off it was the cast on, a complicated procedure involving using a crochet chain and short rows to effect the curved hemline. There ended one attempt to select a pattern before buying the yarn.
I continued my swatching:

First I tried Veronik Avery's Layer Skater's undertop-(that link is actually to someone's blog, but the picture is the best I've seen outside the pattern book). After all, I didn't really need to swatch for this--it is mostly stockinette. My swatches thus far told me that this yarn, Jaeger Aqua, was the perfect gauge for this sweater. I liked the pattern construction (in the round with saddle shoulders), but not the fit. The sweater is designed to be form-fitting with a plain stockinette front. I'm afraid that this yarn is not soft enough for that look. I also think that it is much too thick for a turned hem to look right.
Thinking I could substitute a different edging and front, I looked at Wishbone. The ribbed bottom worked well enough, but the cable, which I love, doesn't look good in this yarn and is difficult to do. This was my third swatch and the one that I didn't finish. After 10 rows into the cable pattern, I knew the tough cotton it wouldn't work for it.
Frustrated, I began checking all my pattern books for a simple cotton pullover. Soon I found Louisa Harding's Sallie striped sweater-(you need to click on Sallie to see it, but it is a great photo). "Oh, lookie!, I thought, "I can use some of my stashed odd balls of yarn for the stripes!" There is nothing like the prospect of using up stash yarn to sell me on a project.
As far as the pattern goes, the only thing I don't like is the length of the sleeves and body. That is easy to fix. Not so easy is the yarn and pattern mis-match. The Aqua yarn gauge is completely wrong, 23 st/4" instead of 20. To add to the yarn problems, there might not be enough of the green yarn for all the stripes. Math can fix the gauge problem, but not the others. In addition, I'm afraid the seams may not look good in this yarn and that the sweater won't look good without shaping.
However, it swatched up super cute.
I can't resist it and am making adjustments to add shaping. One version of the sweater has a peplum (a flare at the hips). I'm using a modified peplum to add waist shaping and will add bustline shaping at the side seams. To avoid lumpy-looking seams, I'll probably knit most of it in the round, joining the sleeves and body and knitting a raglan yoke, so the stripes will match nicely. Alternatively, I might use the shaping from the Skater sweater and have saddle shoulders. I'll likely confound this pattern marriage by making adjustments to the neckline, which is a little higher than I'd like in the Skater, but a little too wide in the Sallie.
I could even incorporate the sleeve cable from the Skater sweater, especially if I don't have enough green yarn for stripes in the sleeves. Wait. I'm bit uncertain that I would go that far, Frankinstein-ing the two patterns together, especially since I don't see any sweaters on Ravelry that have stripes in the body and not in the sleeves. hmmm...
In time, we will see how these two sweater experiments, the Ripple and the Sallie, work out. Looking at them, I'd say I'm headed for a Summer of Stripes. My latest foray into Fair Isle continues the trend. I'll cover that in my next post.
